An experience I had with this model was while signing
with my current apartment complex. Over the summer, I was running low on time
to find a new place to live. My sister strongly suggested I research this one place
off campus. She told me she had lived there for a year and thought very highly
of it. I gathered all the information I could before I called the company.
I ended up talking to someone that I’ll call John for
the purposes of this post. Before I committed to anything, I first had a few
more questions that I needed answered. John was very helpful in getting me the
information I needed. This is in contrast to some of the other apartment
companies I called that either didn’t have the information or didn’t
communicate the information well.
Even still, I was on the fence on whether or not I
would sign a contract. Nevertheless, I took one of their roommate matching tests to see if I’d be able to get a room
anyway. They stressed that they can’t place me in one of the three remaining
rooms unless I was a good enough match. They may have just been trying to
pressure me, but since I needed an apartment, I had no choice but to believe
them.
Since John told me there were so few rooms and that I
had a short time frame, I had no choice to go to the apartment office to sign
the deal. On a side note, I did my absolute best never to sound too eager or desperate.
I also never made it clear I was set on signing a contract. Nor was I sure I
would actually sign. I didn’t expect to bargain, but if that happened for some
reason, I wanted to have some bargaining power.
Again, I ended up
talking with John. He was in charge of the tour. Again, he was very informative
and he seemed very trustworthy. I didn’t feel like he was lying to me or trying
to trick me. Eventually I signed the contract.
All was well and good until a few weeks later. Not
long before classes started, I got an email that said my roommates had been
switched. This didn’t really bother me because I hadn’t met or talked to my
roommates yet, so I had no preference of roommates.
And then, about a day before moving in, I got an
email from my new roommate who mentioned having a dog. My original roommates
didn’t have a dog, which is a big reason I signed the contract. If I knew there’d
be a pet, I would have gone with my second apartment choice. I called the
office, but they didn’t think it was unfair to switch me into an apartment with
a pet without even telling me.
Since then, the people running the apartment have
failed to come through on many different promises. The most notable being the night
shuttle program which was discontinued because the person in charge just didn’t
feel like doing it anymore. Just like the dog situation, I would absolutely not
have signed a contract if I knew they’d do this ahead of time. Thus far, they have been unconvinced
by complaints to reboot the night shuttle program.
So in the end, I don’t think the agent was the
problem. I think the apartment company who hired the agent was the problem. I
believe that John told me what he believed to be the truth, but I don’t think
he had the whole truth. He couldn’t have known I’d be switched or that the
night shuttle program would be discontinued. I don’t even know if the apartment
company could have expected that. Nevertheless, the apartment company filled
another room, the agent they hired still got paid, and I’m out of luck.
Alas, I believe the town is now filled with predator landlords. This has always been something of a problem, which is why there is a tenants union, but I think it has gotten worse with the construction of the high rises on Green street as a result of the undergraduate population having increased. This market cries for some regulation so that things like what happened to you don't become a commonplace.
ReplyDeleteNow, on the flip side, and thinking about this from managing risk, I'd definitely want to know about my roommate before signing a lease and I wouldn't let some third party do that for me. I'd want to meet directly with the potential roommate. So on this one, the question is why it got late in the season for you before you resolved the issue. Addressing this earlier would have helped to reduce the risk. It wouldn't have done anything about the night shuttle thing. I don't see how you could have known about that in advance. But on the roommate thing, I believe you could have been more proactive.